Philately: Investment or Hobby?
Quote from Steve on November 15, 2026, 6:58 pmThe article, "Stamp collecting has Footsie licked for making money (Rosie Murray-West, The Daily Telegraph, March 4, 2006), was written 20 years ago at a time when SG (Stanley Gibbons) was actively and controversially promoting stamps as an investment. SG largely created the British stamp hobby and market based on coloured bits of printed and perforated paper with no inherent value.
It would be intersting to learn from collectors in "the top end of stamp collecting", people you would expect to know a thing or two about money and how to keep it, people who responded positively to SG's marketing, just how much they have realised on their investment today, indeed if they still include stamps in their investment portfolio. In my opinion stamps are only ever worth what you can sell them for. Buying stamps is easy. Selling them is the tricky bit. Stocks and shares are easier to offload at realistic market prices.
The newpaper cutting introduces the start of an SG marketing campaign to promote stamp collecting as an alternative investment asset and economic safe haven by creating benchmark price indices, offering structured portfolios, and pitching rare stamps to high-net-worth individuals. At more-or-less the start of this campaign The Guardian, (8 August 2008), wrote "SG, the stamps and historical signatures dealer, has reported increased profits, thanks to investors switching to collectables as a hedge against soaring inflation".
"The benefits of investing in collectables as an alternative asset class have never been clearer," the company's chairman, Martin Bralsford, confidently stated. "The investment argument is fast becoming too compelling to ignore - not only do rare stamps and historical signatures provide a means of diversification and a safe haven in difficult economic conditions, but also provide a hedge against inflation." No doubt, this was exactly what SG's stockholders needed to be told. However, fast forward eight years and they were reading "Stanley Gibbons: Licked. Stamp dealer’s problems highlight flaws with alternative investments. (Lex, July 2016.)
By 2017 SG's financial results were reporting “another difficult year for the group”. According to the FT (Financial Times), (Oct 2 2017) "Losses are swelling fast for SG which is somewhat at the mercy of ... its bank". In June 9 2021 the FT reported that the "World’s most valuable stamp sold for $8.3m to London dealer. Price tag for 1856 One-Cent Magenta." The buyer was SG. The sBritish Guiana 1c Megenta stamp was valued at more than a third of SG's market capitalisation. SG had bought it as an 'investment' and was soon attempting to sell fractional shares of the stamp to investors. In July 22, 2022 the FT reported that "SG proposes delisting under shareholder pressure. .... Phoenix Asset Management seeks to acquire stamp collector and remove it from the Aim market". Oops!
If you are wondering where this is going, my point is that buying a stamp as an investment from SG was not a good. idea. It's a hobby, not an investment! It is also a hobby also for the wealthy who buy better stamps than we can afford. There are many other long-standing dealers who supply the top-end of the market who have not had such financial problems selling 'investments'. From my rather low-level, down-in-the-trenches perspective I will only ever buy a stamp or postal history if I have a compelling reason to do so, like it compliments my collection. But I will never buy them expecting a growth in value. Those days are gone and the market too uncertain.
Some time ago I bought an item on eBay for £100. I immediately recognised it for what it was and I had to have it. I happily parted with my money because this was a genuinely unique cornerstone item for one of my displays. It was originally sold in 1928 for £27 10/-. That would be the equivalent of approximately £2,242.50 or $2,967.39 USD today.What a fantastic bargain! I have never agonised over the money spent on it. I have something remarkable of my own. As my my very modest £100 paid today would only be worth £1.23 or about $3 USD in 1928, the question is: 'Did the buyer overpay in 1928? Or was he merely just buying something he absolutely had to have?'
The article, "Stamp collecting has Footsie licked for making money (Rosie Murray-West, The Daily Telegraph, March 4, 2006), was written 20 years ago at a time when SG (Stanley Gibbons) was actively and controversially promoting stamps as an investment. SG largely created the British stamp hobby and market based on coloured bits of printed and perforated paper with no inherent value.
It would be intersting to learn from collectors in "the top end of stamp collecting", people you would expect to know a thing or two about money and how to keep it, people who responded positively to SG's marketing, just how much they have realised on their investment today, indeed if they still include stamps in their investment portfolio. In my opinion stamps are only ever worth what you can sell them for. Buying stamps is easy. Selling them is the tricky bit. Stocks and shares are easier to offload at realistic market prices.
The newpaper cutting introduces the start of an SG marketing campaign to promote stamp collecting as an alternative investment asset and economic safe haven by creating benchmark price indices, offering structured portfolios, and pitching rare stamps to high-net-worth individuals. At more-or-less the start of this campaign The Guardian, (8 August 2008), wrote "SG, the stamps and historical signatures dealer, has reported increased profits, thanks to investors switching to collectables as a hedge against soaring inflation".
"The benefits of investing in collectables as an alternative asset class have never been clearer," the company's chairman, Martin Bralsford, confidently stated. "The investment argument is fast becoming too compelling to ignore - not only do rare stamps and historical signatures provide a means of diversification and a safe haven in difficult economic conditions, but also provide a hedge against inflation." No doubt, this was exactly what SG's stockholders needed to be told. However, fast forward eight years and they were reading "Stanley Gibbons: Licked. Stamp dealer’s problems highlight flaws with alternative investments. (Lex, July 2016.)
By 2017 SG's financial results were reporting “another difficult year for the group”. According to the FT (Financial Times), (Oct 2 2017) "Losses are swelling fast for SG which is somewhat at the mercy of ... its bank". In June 9 2021 the FT reported that the "World’s most valuable stamp sold for $8.3m to London dealer. Price tag for 1856 One-Cent Magenta." The buyer was SG. The sBritish Guiana 1c Megenta stamp was valued at more than a third of SG's market capitalisation. SG had bought it as an 'investment' and was soon attempting to sell fractional shares of the stamp to investors. In July 22, 2022 the FT reported that "SG proposes delisting under shareholder pressure. .... Phoenix Asset Management seeks to acquire stamp collector and remove it from the Aim market". Oops!
If you are wondering where this is going, my point is that buying a stamp as an investment from SG was not a good. idea. It's a hobby, not an investment! It is also a hobby also for the wealthy who buy better stamps than we can afford. There are many other long-standing dealers who supply the top-end of the market who have not had such financial problems selling 'investments'. From my rather low-level, down-in-the-trenches perspective I will only ever buy a stamp or postal history if I have a compelling reason to do so, like it compliments my collection. But I will never buy them expecting a growth in value. Those days are gone and the market too uncertain.
Some time ago I bought an item on eBay for £100. I immediately recognised it for what it was and I had to have it. I happily parted with my money because this was a genuinely unique cornerstone item for one of my displays. It was originally sold in 1928 for £27 10/-. That would be the equivalent of approximately £2,242.50 or $2,967.39 USD today.What a fantastic bargain! I have never agonised over the money spent on it. I have something remarkable of my own. As my my very modest £100 paid today would only be worth £1.23 or about $3 USD in 1928, the question is: 'Did the buyer overpay in 1928? Or was he merely just buying something he absolutely had to have?'
